Owen’s presentation of war and soldiers in ‘Dulce Et Decorum Est’ and ‘Disabled’ Essay


Once World War 1 broke out in 1914, most of The uk rejoiced.

There is a dash to join the army and a lot of young men do as they made a decision it was their patriotic duty to fight for their ‘mother country’. Many also joined up with the military because they will thought the war will be an excursion and because battle was being glorified and made in to an exciting game at that time. Like a soldier offered you a higher status and a community respect.

These ideas had been reflected in numerous early conflict poems such as Rupert Brooke’s ‘The Soldier’ and Jessie Pope’s ‘Who’s for the sport? ‘ Inside the poem the ‘The Soldier’ Brooke gives war a clean, sanitized and idealistic look, such as making Great britain seem the right place and associating Great britain with only good words (For case peace and friends frivolity. ) Brooke also makes war sound romantic as he makes it audio dashing and glorious like a cavalry impose and he then omits all of the actual struggling with and getting injured, gassed, taken, maimed or injured. The poem is around being a main character and becoming taken to heaven.

Patriotism is reflected in the poem because Brooke can make it sound just like you are British and you perish for Britain, you happen to be precious: England’s ‘richer dust’ is a part of you and as you die is made the terrain where you have dropped part of Britain. There is a replication of Britain and anytime England is definitely mentioned good stuff are stated about it. There is the implication that Goodness is in England’s area, this is shown in the poem as Brooke makes the visitor think that the soldiers are being blessed by God. For example ‘blest by team of house. ‘ Brooke also suggests that it is your patriotic work to go and fight for the country that ‘bore, shaped to make you aware’ and offered you existence. You must pay off ‘her’ by simply fighting England’s enemies.

Great britain is also personified as a mom because conflict was a call to man’s protective behavioral instinct and possibly to his valiance. As the war advanced the landscapes about the war altered as well. Even more people halted thinking that the war was glorious and exciting plus they began to appreciate just how dangerous and dangerous war was. They also realised the cost of conflict was harming to the region, not just financially but likewise through by huge amounts of the useless and injured.

People started to wonder if the sacrifice of such men was worth the advantages of the battle and whether there was also any point out the warfare. The war poems created at that time started to show this contrast. The early, na�ve poetry of Brooke and Pere contrast together with the experienced poetry of Owen.

The suggestions that they acquired on conflict were clearly different. In the poem Azucarado et Decorum Est Owen provides the visitor with a reasonable presentation from the war inside the trenches as well as the soldiers struggling in the battle. Owen gives the reader the perils of that the soldier experienced everyday, (for example dangers of fighting and being shot or gassed, ). Owen uses incredibly physical and graphic imagery to describe what goes on (For case in point ‘Bent double, like aged beggars beneath sacks, knock-kneed, coughing just like hags, all of us cursed through the sludge. ‘ and ‘ Men marched asleep.

A large number of had misplaced their boot styles but limped on, bloodstream shod, every went boring; all blind; drunk with fatigue. ‘) As you can see actually from these couple of lines in the poem Owen uses physical explanation to help someone visualise what is going on and what it was like to be out there. There exists some very graphical imagery in the poem, (For example’Flound’ring just like a man burning down or lime… Dim within green sea I saw him drowning. In all my dreams, before my own helpless look, he plunges at me personally guttering, choking, and drowning’).

Also inside the poem there is some more graphical description about how exactly what happened to the poor soldier after this individual got gassed: (‘white sight writhing in the face, his hanging face, like a devils sick of trouble, at every shot, the blood come gargling in the froth-corrupted lungs’). Owen as well in the composition places the reader in the genuine experience (For example ‘If in some obstructing dreams that you too could pace behind the wagon we all flung him in. ‘) By re-creating a specific second in the composition, the gas attack Owen lets someone “enter” and stay part of the composition.

Owen would not just put the reader in the experience he also directly addresses the reader by using phrases like “my friends” and “you” inside the poem (For example ‘If you could hear…. My friend, you will not…. ‘) There is also reader involvement in the “Old Lie” at the end from the poem since Owen says with certainty that in case you could observe what it was like here you should not notify the children the Old Lie?

The tone of the poem is incredibly bitter and angry and some parts there is a incredibly sarcastic and negative frame of mind In the lines ‘If in a few smothering wish you too may pace…’ what “if” and “you” claim that he is upset because the expression ‘if’ shows that the reader doesn’t know just how bad it was out there as well as the word ‘you’ separates the reader from Owen and suggests that the reader is secure at home. You will discover ironic moments in the composition as it of the poem is sarcastic. The last lines contradict it of the composition “Dulce ou Decorum Est” which means that ‘it is sweet and directly to die to your country’.

This really is a sarcastic comment inside the poem while Owen was trying to show the reader it turned out not right to die to your country. Owen also composed another poem called Incapable which contrast with Golosina et… as in Dulce et… Owen can be describing the realities of war when in Impaired Owen is writing about the results or aftermath from the war for one particular terribly wounded soldier.

The poem is not as physically or perhaps graphically descriptive as Dulce et… was; Disabled much more reflective and sorrowful, (for example ‘ Now he may never experience again just how girls waists are, or how warm their subtle hands; ‘) There is quieter language used in Disabled, for example not as ‘loud’ or surprising words had been used by Owen in Handicapped unlike Deleitoso et… The poem shows how he lost his youth, long term, limbs, hope and his typical life and exactly how knows he has to are in hospitals looking forward to death performing things that only the rules consider wise. The young man fought for his country and was wounded for it nevertheless he is not treated just like a hero.

He can shoved to a hospital like a diseased person and Owen stresses his bitterness about how he is remedied in the poem. (for example ‘All of these touch him like a lot of queer disease’) Owen focuses on one regular young man yet this person represents millions of others like him and it showed the reader that their close friend, husband, father could be facing or could be soon facing the consequences of fighting to your country similar to this young man performed. It also lets the reader understand the perils of battle with a personal level.

In the poem there is a issue being asked to the target audience although not immediately, and the problem asked is actually the sacrifice of countless young men’s futures, lives, hopes and dreams was worth the countries engagement in the war, and once again as in Golosina et… Owens answer is not a, that it is not really right to chuck your future away for the or for your country should be expected this a person. The poem therefore stocks and shares some of Golosina et… bitterness and anger at the conflict.

I can admire aspects of Brooke’s poem after reading Owens as Brooke was an idealistic possibly romantic person and he was obsessed with war and also Brooke was a patriot and I adore him as he was not not wanting to sign for the armed service and these kinds of character points are reflected in his poem. Brooke was however na�ve and unsophisticated so he really didn’t know totally about conflict and this as well is mirrored in his poem.

  • Category: Warfare
  • Words: 1491
  • Pages: 5
  • Project Type: Essay

Need an Essay Writing Help?
We will write a custom essay sample on any topic specifically for you
Do Not Waste Your Time
Only $13.90 / page