Qualitative Research Assignment Essay
1 . Was there a definite statement in the aims with the research?
Certainly. In the document, the aim of your research was to understand the experience of members, their information about type 2 diabetes, as well as the factors of medication faithfulness in Malaysia. According to Susan (2010), the five components of PICOT are human population, issue, framework, outcome, and time. In respect to Al-Qazaz et ing (2011), the PICOT was presented by researcher inside the study were, P: Type 2diabetes patients with obtaining of hypoglycemic medication.
Only $13.90 / page
I: Identifying participants’ perception, and the knowledge about type 2 diabetes disease and medication. C: USM clinic of Malaysia, the place that the study took place. O: It can help people living with type 2 diabetes to get a diverse understanding by relating with other people’s experiences.
Big t: March and April of 2009. Qualitative PICOT is known as a framework to aid in making effective specialized medical question in a step-by step manner (Melnyk and Fineout, 2010). According to Polit and Beck (2012), semi-structured interview can offer rich and detailed data during trend study. From this study, a phenomenological way was used to described the essence the research.
It is to understand the experiences of diabetic patients in Malaysia, and explore their knowledge about the prescription drugs that they have been taking. According to Judith (2007), qualitative research is seen as its aims to know the experiences and attitudes of patients. In brief, a qualitative methodology is appropriate to this research.
3. Was your research design appropriate to address the seeks of the study? Yes. Relating to NCBI (2014), a Phenomenological analyze can probably check out participant’s were living experience, morals about the efficacy with the medication , side-effects of drug and participants’ adherence for the treatment program.
By the rectangular, in this article, the aim is to be familiar with participants’ experience and explore their knowledge and medication devotedness related on type 2 diabetes. Therefore , phenomenological procedure is appropriate to address the is designed of the exploration. The advantages of Phenomenological research is to expose patients’ morals and encounters by a flexible way to research the respondents’ frame of mind, and allowing for deep understanding about knowledge and feeling of participants (Polit and Beck, 2012).
Yet , its constraint is that trials are often tiny band and the researchers are generally not attempting to extend the studies. 4. Was the recruitment strategy appropriate to the aims in the research? Certainly.
The researcher recruited members from USM clinic and who were clinically diagnosed type 2 diabetes when taking on hypoglycemic medications by using a convenience testing. According to HRDAG (2013), convenience testing is to generate participants via a particular specialized medical setting during data variety of a qualitative research. Furthermore, convenience sample is easy and efficient to extract the very best possible information from the fresh cases in the sample, right up until there is no new data could possibly be obtained and the redundancy of data saturation was achieved (Polit and Beck, 2012).
Nevertheless , convenience sampling may not be a preferred sampling in qualitative research because of unable to reveal the most information-rich sources as well as the representative of the citizenry (Polit and Beck, 2012). In this article, your data was just obtained in one specific medical clinic, that would impact the credibility of result, including the adverse effects of medication , plus the satisfaction rates from wellness providers. It would be better in the event the researcher use purpose testing into the examine.
Purpose sample is to select participants based upon specific functions, and it is generally used in qualitative research (Polit and Beck, 2012). it may achieve representativeness from the population and supply credibility from the result, since the researcher will not only focus on a single clinic during recruitment of participants. your five. Were the info collected in a way that addressed the research issues? Certainly. A semi-structured interview was created for data collecting in the research.
Semi-structured interview is a paper-based interview guide that contain open-ended concerns and the participant to uses (RWJF, 2008). Moreover, Semi-structured interview offer rich, in depth information inside the phenomenon examine (Polit and Beck, 2012). In the examine, the investigator has defined in-depth interview to explore patients’ beliefs and experiences.
Besides, a agreement form was signed by participants before interview, an immediate tell cellphone contact to get arranging a moments of interview. Further more, all the interview has been audiotaped, and the specialist did line by line analysis and coding the info to identify the main element themes. The researcher interpreted to the individuals who cannot understand The english language during the meeting with by translation from an employee nurse to avoid bias that might affect the findings.
In short, the information collected had been fully dealt with the research concern of this research. 6. Provides the relationship between researcher and participants been adequately regarded? Yes. Qualitative researchers need to develop a good relationships with participants inside the study to establish credibility (Polit and Beck, 2012). Inside the article, each of the participants had been informed the objective of this study, and a consent form was signed by every one of them.
The researcher also made phone call to prepare time and place that individuals would like to choose for each interview. Besides, they are really allowed to communicate their own views at the time of interview. From the analysis above we can see the members have been completely respected by the researcher to find their trust. Therefore , the relationship between investigator and individuals has been sufficiently considered through this study (Al-Qazaz et al 2011).
However , there was not any mention regarding reflexivity by the researcher in this article. According to RWJF(2008), it described that reflexivity is a process use for exam researcher’s relationship for the respondent that refers to the way the researcher’s beliefs, beliefs, friends and passions influence his/her research. It would be better if it is described about how the researcher located herself or himself inside the study, readers can determine how it affect the info obtaining, that will gain the findings in the research to be more reliable (Polit and Beck, 2012). Further more, the analysis was as well approved by the local ethics panel. In short, the ethical issues have been used into the analyze as well.
There were no coercion could be found in the study. Yet , the researcher did not talk about about the confidentiality and exactly how was data protected. Besides, they did certainly not mention just how many times individuals understanding were checked prior to the consent contact form given. According to Polit and Beck (2012), it can be described that this must cope with ethical problems if the research involving individuals, because the human rights should be protected. Additionally, the specialist mentioned all their data had been analyzed through the use of means of a standard content research framework.
Its aim was achieved by a appropriate phenomenological design with this study which have been discussed showcased two. Moreover, the rectitud and quality can also result in developing standing of qualitative research, and the five criterion to get evaluation the trustworthiness in the research use in credibility, consistency, confirmability, transferability, and genuineness (Polit and Beck, 2012). In the examine, a phenomenological design was conducted which has a semi-structured interview of data collection, and code method for info analysis. this is sufficiently turned out its believability, dependability, and confirmability. Therefore , it can be explained the data analysis of this study is sufficient demanding.
Further, a convenience testing recruited individuals and remove the greatest likely information to obtain data vividness for its rigour. Meanwhile, the ethical issues has been taken into consideration by the researchers to gain as well as the individual’s rights. On the other side, the specialist demonstrated their very own limitations what they aware of the study to enhance the findings even more clearly and accurately. Relating to quantitative conclusions, it is not generalizable that can be applied to entire populations, however , it is generalizable in a way this especially pertinent to nursing practice in which there exists an expectation that clinical finding, and provide knowledge about individual experiences to readers for future research.
Thus it could be seen, the study is quite important. However , in qualitative analysis, the CASP is helped to understanding people’s existed experience and explore participant’s experience of taking the drugs, morals about the efficacy of the drug, side-effects and the faithfulness of treatment regime. A phenomenological method has been utilized in the qualitative study through a semi-structured interview, convenience testing and code to reveal patient’s beliefs and experiences, and allowing understanding of the knowledge and coping approaches in which the quantitative research is struggling to cover.
More, in this qualitative study, sample size is are likely to be small , and and the locating is not really generalized(Polit and Beck, 2012). Both of research workers have considered validity, findings, and its particular relevance. However , in the qualitative article, in the event the researcher make use of a purpose sampling method and mention regarding reflexivity and member checking out during data collection, that could enhance quality of the results to be more accurate.
Reference 1 . Aveyard H and Sharp P (2009) A Beginner’s Guide to Evidence Based Practice in Health insurance and Social Care Professions. Glasgow: Open University or college Press. installment payments on your Al-Qazaz They would, Hassali Meters and Sulaiman S (2011) Perception and knowledge of people with diabetes mellitus type 2 in Malaysia about their disease and medication: A qualitative study. Research in Social and Administrative Chemist 7: 180-191.
3. Bandolier (no date) Intention-to-treat analysis (ITT) Sold at: http://www.medicine.ox.ac.uk/bandolier/booth/glossary/itt.html [Accessed 5/92014]. 4. Chan Z, Fung Y and Chien W(2013) Bracketing in Phenomenology: Simply Undertaken in the Data Collection and Examination Process? The Qualitative Survey.
Volume 18, Article fifty nine, 1-9 [online] Available at: http://www.nova.edu/ssss/QR/QR18/chan59.pdf(accessed 26/10/2014) 6. Human Rights Data Examination Group(2013) Ease Samples: What they are, and what they should (and should not) be used pertaining to [online] Offered by: https://hrdag.org/convenience-samples-what-they-are/ (accessed 3/9/2014) several. LONDON SCHOOL of HYGLENE and EXOTIC MEDICINE(no date) Qualitative methods useful for agriculture, nutrition and health programmes. [online]Available at: https://ble.lshtm.ac.uk/pluginfile.php/54407/mod_resource/content/107/ANH101/sessions/S1S2/ANH101_S1S2_040_010.html(accessed 28/10/2014) eight.
Melnyk B. M and Fineout-Overholt E (Eds) (2010) Evidence-Based Practice in Breastfeeding & Healthcare: A Guide to Finest Practice (2nd edition). UK: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins. 9. MEDECINS SANS FRONTIERES(2007) A Guide to Applying Qualitative Study Methodology [online] Available at: http://fieldresearch.msf.org/msf/bitstream/10144/84230/1/Qualitative%20research%20methodology.pdf (accessed 28/10/2014) 10. Melling A, Ali B, Jeff E and Leaper G (2001) Effects of preoperative temperatures rising on the incidence of injury infection following clean surgical treatment: a randomized controlled trial. The lancet, 358: 876-880.
11. NCBI(2014) A phenomenological study to explore the experiences of Ugandan ladies that have been subject to transvaginal ultrasound [online] Offered at: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4175835/(accessed 1/9/2014) 12. NCBI (2011) Qualitative Research Conclusions as Proof: Utility in Nursing Practice. [online] Available at: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3021785/ [Accessed 13 Nov.
2014]. 14. Robert Wood Johnson Foundation (2008) Qualitative Research Guidelines Job Semi-structured Interviews [online] Offered at: http://www.qualres.org/HomeSemi-3629.html [Accessed eleven Nov. 2014]. 15.
Robert Wood Johnson Foundation (2008) Qualitative Research Guidelines Task what is reflexivity [online] Sold at: http://www.qualres.org/HomeRefl-3703.html [Accessed doze Nov. 2014]. 16. Susan B. H, Fineout-Overholt Electronic, Melnyk N. M and Williamson T. M(2010) Requesting the Clinical Question: An important Step in Evidence-Based Practice. The American Log of Nursing jobs.
Vol. one hundred ten, No . several. Available at: http://www.nursingcenter.com/lnc/pdfjournal?AID=982283&an=00000446-201003000-00028&Journal_ID=&Issue_ID=(accessed 22/10/2014)