feltner versus columbia

Pages: 1

In 1991, Columbia Photographs Television broken agreements certification multiple tvs series. These kinds of series shown on 3 television channels, all owned by C. Elvin Feltner. The violations took place because of Feltner’s work of delinquent payments, yet did not stop Feltner’s place from airing the television series’. This ended in Columbia suing Feltner intended for copyright intrusion. Columbia in that case made the attempt to restore statutory damage under the Copyright laws Act. Feltner was denied the right to a jury trial and Columbia was powerful in obtaining statutory damages.

The Court of Appeals avowed that nor the Copyright Act nor the Seventh Amendment offered rights to a jury trial regarding lawful damages. In support of Columbia Photographs Television, the Court of Appeals organised that inside the Copyright Work, there is no legal right to a jury trial if the copyright owner wishes to recoup statutory injuries. Section 504 promises that rather than jury determining the amount of statutory damages being rewarded, the Court shall set the quantity as they see fit. If the The courtroom views the case as one of copyright laws infringement that is certainly deliberate or perhaps innocent, they might increase or decrease the value of statutory damages. With out a jury within the Court, the components may only be seen as the Judge. Nevertheless , the Copyright Act does not use that term when ever delivering decisions of real damage and profits. Very much to his dismay, Feltner’s only dependence was for the address of the constitutional problem. Although the copyright act would not grant the fundamental right of getting a court to trial statutory problems, the Seventh Amendment promises the right to jury trial upon all elements pertaining to being statutory problems, namely, the amount. Despite the sculpture being muted on the level, the 7th Amendment does include the right to a jury trial, as a result insinuating, the right for a jury to assess how much statutory problems.

The truth was turned. In spite of the normal law certainly not demonstrating the dire need for a jury trial, providing citizens with fair wisdom has been a practice among each of our nation since the court of equity in Britain. Columbia had argued that lawful damages were equitable, therefore , the Seventh Amendment would not apply and the need for a jury trial was nonexistent. In opposition to the argument of Columbia Photographs, a jury trial is necessary to maintain preservation of the common-law rights. Being statutory damages may deliver purposes usually associated with legal relief, just like compensation and punishment. The last decision in the Court organised that in spite of section 504 of the Copyright laws Act’s silence, Feltner was provided the justification to a jury trial. This kind of included the justification to a jury decision regarding the amount of statutory damages. Keeping word to the historic evidence at the rear of the Seventh Amendment, Proper rights Clarence Jones concluded that, “there is clear and direct historical evidence that juries, both as a general matter and copyright situations, set the quantity for damages awarded into a successful plaintiff. ” This individual also predicted that this bottom line should make jury identifying the complete sum of lawful damages under Section 504, in order to continue to be loyal to production that is the common-law of trial simply by jury.

Following this decision, the jury awarded $72, 000 in statutory injuries for each with the works infringed upon. The whole award came to be $31. 68 million us dollars, three and half instances the amount the Judge could have awarded in the prior bench trial. Feltner argued that the Supreme Court’s rulings said statutory damages to be out of constitute and gap. The court of appeals rejected this argument and approved the $31. 68 million court award. Feltner then produced an attempt to be heard to get a second period at the Supreme Court. This attempt was unsuccessful and the $31. sixty-eight million award was left intact.