Moral Relativism, Positivism, Deontology, Bribery


Excerpt from Term Paper:

Ethical Concerns Facing the Army Leadership Today

We will write a custom essay sample on
A Fever You Can't Sweat Out by Panic! At the Disco
or any similar topic specifically for you
Do Not Waste
Your Time

Only $13.90 / page

America military is definitely facing a sponsor of moral issues today. A number of allegations in recent months concerning questionable honest behavior – as well as that which can be decidedly underhanded – possess afflicted virtually every segment of the armed forces such as Navy, Usaf, National Guard, and the Marines. Moreover, these kinds of instances of underhanded and immoral behavior have also been widely reported in the media, which is impacting on public notion of this branch of the country in order that the public’s view of Armed service leadership’s unethical conduct can be described as snapshot from the ethical complications facing the Army today. Allegations have got involved a number of offenses including bribery, cheating on exams, sexual approaches, inebriation, medication use, unwarranted behavior in combat circumstances, and others. This paper will illustrate a variety of dimensions of this situation, including the need for values at the two an individual and organizational level, issues with the two lower level and upper level personnel, honest concerns during times of war along with peace, and an the use of personal integrity with that at a system extensive, organizational level. Today businesses strive to become viewed by public as the greater good, using their affect and capacity to elicit great change. When the ethical beliefs of the Soldier aligns together with the ethical criteria of the Military that synchronization establishes a shared worth system guiding the organization through conflict or perhaps peacetime.

One of the most rudimentary level of ethics takes place at the specific level. Therefore , in order to curb unethical behavior and to circumscribe its effect within the larger organization of various branches of the military which unit like a collective, it is necessary to identify the different stages through which ethics becomes important for a person, plus the psychological effects of both honest and unethical decisions. A person is certain to face ethical problems throughout the several stages of his or her your life, and in doing this can consider a variety of moral perspectives to assist with this procedure. There are essentially two different aspects that define the notion of an ethical dilemma. A great ethical issue occurs each time a situation develops in which either a person is not sure as to what the proper intervention is to increase right and minimize incorrect, or a condition in which the course of action that maximizes right and minimizes wrong is disputes wit somebody’s inclination (U. S. Military services, no day, p. 7). Such conditions develop throughout an individual’s life once she or he matures for the age in which he or she is able to discern from wrong and encounters circumstances that challenge is or her conceiving of right and wrong. Additionally , there are numerous different moral theories that one may utilize to support with honest dilemmas. Consequentialism, for example , may be the branch of values that is convinced that although there may be areas of moral relativism, the results of an actions ultimately decide whether or not it truly is ethically defensible. Deontology, yet , posits the viewpoint that some practices and methods of action happen to be inherently ethical, and should continually be followed no matter f the result. Utilitarianism is another ethical point of view that is somewhat a crossbreed of the aforementioned perspectives and propounds the viewpoint the course of action that is certainly most defensible is that which usually produces the highest utility or common very good.

It is worth noting why these various facets of ethical dilemmas that are encountered throughout the different stages of life turn into somewhat made easier when put on military personnel, and to army leadership specifically. The armed forces is an organization that has a very clear code of ethics and highly certain rules and regulations intended for conduct and for a number of conditions that its personnel frequently encounter. Therefore , there are hardly ever ethical problems in which armed forces personnel are not aware of how they should certainly ethically work – perhaps the most eclectic of such situations entail combat and instances of battle. Outside of overcome situations, the principle kind of ethical issue military staff face is that which juxtaposes what they find out they should do with that which they are inclined to carry out. Therefore , once analyzing the psychological impacts of moral or dishonest decision-making, the ramifications become similarly lucid. Those who participate in ethical patterns in the military can relax knowing that they are behaving in accordance with the highest virtues of their organization associated with their region. From an individual perspective, it is necessary to realize that empirical proof supports the fact that “Hypothesis 1: Ethical leadership provides a positive impact on follower meaning identity. Speculation 2: Ethical leadership contains a positive influence on follower mental empowerment” (Zhu, 2008). The implications of such hypotheses – each of which was authenticated by the facts utilized in Zhu’s article (2008) are that the effects of ethical decision-making cause a feeling of self-worth and positivism for the. Conversely, although the individual may possibly enjoy the benefits of underhanded behavior, psychologically the individual is still aware of the simple fact that this individual engaged in underhanded behavior. Morally, that person is aware he or she has done wrong. Yet , there is a penchant for these kinds of a person to engage in similar acts of patterns due to the identified benefits of such an action – especially if individual not been caught intended for the breach of ethics. Thus, unethical behavior can actually provide the government for continuing unethical habit.

Again, because the military is such a tightly-knit unit which values cohesion and solidarity above individuality and autonomy, it is essential to evaluate the effect of moral influences about individuals. These influences regularly take the form of a group energetic in this particular context, that may greatly identify the way your personal values contribute to one’s actions. Because of the overwhelming dependence on a string of order and the basic camaraderie that accompanies many military workers and which in turn intrinsically distinguishes them by civilians, the phenomenon where a mob attitude may dominate is a very true component of lots of the ongoing honest issues the armed forces can be facing. Johnson (1974) describes this essential aspect of the military while the devotion syndrome, through which

This is the practice wherein queries of right or wrong are subordinated to the overriding value of loyalty towards the boss. Loyaltycan become every consuming. Additionally, it becomes risky when a legitimate, wholesome dedication to the boss degenerates into covering on with him, covering things from him, or certainly not differing with him if he is incorrect (p. 37).

It is interesting to note that there appears to be quite a few of the more recent integrity violations inside the armed forces that have actually engaged the complicity of superior ranking representatives. On the one hand, the unofficial code of ethics in which armed forces personnel keep together and rely on the other person in times of adversity and non-adversity presents a particular problem facing the army with its army issues. Nevertheless , there are a number of other instances in which army leaders who’ve been involved with the service well beyond the decade-plus warfare theater in Afghanistan and Iraq have facilitated unethical behavior, furthermore to basically propagating it. Prior to the recent developments by which there have been common media reports of unethical behavior inside the armed solutions, such circumstances involving army leadership had been rarely reported. When evaluating the fact that military leadership may also be flawed from an ethical perspective and actually triggering some of the immoral behavior between subordinates, it seems that

The more worrying ones are definitely the upper-ranking representatives who have presumably been squared away pertaining to 20-plus years, doing what they’re performing and then are failing during these embarrassing ways involving alcoholic beverages, sex and moneythere’s anything going on on the that level thatis fresh (Bowman, 2014).

Such a press release suggests the real and disturbing possibility that armed forces leadership is really contributing to the ethical problems facing the armed forces today.

Since these kinds of behavior is on a regular basis reported towards the mass media today, it is essential to look at this influence on the overall organizational culture from the U. S. military. By an outsider’s perspective, the effect of the media would appear to have little sway over the approach that the company culture with the military features. What the media’s sensationalizing with the events of impropriety regarding armed forces superiors and subordinates does, eventually, is help to create a climate in which the public will clamor for transform. In fact , to best reduce such a predicament before it will take place, the military would do well to cope with these issues itself – which can be exactly what it has been doing. Due to these instances of underhanded conduct, there has been a concerted effort for individuals in the Pentagon to try to restructure certain facets of the military’s tradition to address these types of problems. Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel has openly urged the leaders of the respective twigs of the military to take further action to curb these ethical problems. Additionally , “the Pentagon has picked

Prev post Next post
Get your ESSAY template and tips for writing right now