how powerful are different methods in reducing


Jail, non-custodial sentences and therapy seem every failed in reducing recidivism; however , there may be little and limited proof to support non-custodial sentences, as well as some people think if rehabilitation could be executed effectively, it could work. Although the advantage of penitentiary is keeping our society from risky people, in terms of reducing recidivism rate, the result of prison is discouraging. The public generally think that imprisonment is safer for areas; however , it seems powerless to deter inmates from doing crime again.

In the article, “Study shows building prisons did not prevent repeat crimes, Sibel Butterfield (2002) cites a large-scale analyze of recidivism from the Bureau of Proper rights Statistics, which usually investigated approximately 272, 111 former prisoners in 12-15 states during the first three years after released. It located that 67% of inmates broke the law again in three years soon after their discharge in 1994. It is astonished that it does not make any difference to recidivism rate which was examined in 1950’s, and it is actually 5% more than the study required for 1983.

Additionally , it suggested that the even more rearrest documents a legal has, the larger recidivism rate he offers. The inmates who have more than 15 before arrests include 82. 1% of recidivism rate. Nevertheless, according to Emily Kingham’s article (2006), she believes that jail forces offenders to feel dissapointed about and think about their behaviour; as for the main reason that criminals cannot deny the attraction of committing new criminal offenses is because of limited provided support. In spite of this kind of, some professionals have publicly stated that jail does not work in terms of reducing recidivism rate (Considering the alternatives 1978; Finckenauer 1988).

A few limited data has shown that non-custodial phrases may decrease recidivism; irrespective of some authorities being sceptical about their wanted achievements. On the one hand, alternative paragraphs can help government save money and alleviate over-cramped number of crooks in penitentiary (Considering the alternatives 1978). On the other hand, Kingham(2006) points out that alternative sentences do nothing nevertheless return criminals to their original circumstances, which result in unawareness of their criminal offenses and the onsequences. One study indicated that through one of alternative sentences, intensive probation, recidivism rate is less than 20%; yet , the evidence could be weak as the study is not completely put into practice (Considering the alternatives 1978). Furthermore, inside the Minnesota, option sentences have already been successfully used to keep felony rate certainly not increasing, nonetheless it may not be certain because of the source not being affirmed (Considering the alternatives 1978).

While some people argue treatment is also failed in minimizing recidivism charge, some creators counter that if government could support rehabilitation, recidivism rate might decrease. In line with the article, “Prison, James U. Finckenauer (1988) cites several studies, which will shows that although the government has already provided with very good rehabilitation programmes, they cannot accomplish reformatory of inmates.

On the other hand, this position is definitely contested by simply Joan Petersilis (cited in Butterfield 2002), a professor of criminology at the College or university of Washington dc at Irvine and a professional on leitspruch, who says that state governments spent this kind of little funds on therapy programs that inmates do not receive satisfactory help with drug addition, operate skill and preparation for a new life, which may business lead increasing recidivism rate. Butterfield (2002) additional cites the statement by Mr. Travis, who as well argues that criminals return to crime.


  • Category: essay
  • Words: 573
  • Pages: 2
  • Project Type: Essay

Need an Essay Writing Help?
We will write a custom essay sample on any topic specifically for you
Do Not Waste Your Time
Only $13.90 / page